A literature research paper is not too different from other types of research essays that you might have written before. In a nutshell, it is an attempt to develop a series of ideas with a view to proving a certain hypothesis about one or more given texts (PRIMARY SOURCES). In getting to this end your intuition and intellect will play the largest part, yet you will also have to resort to the ideas and opinions of more expert readers who have published their thoughts in articles and books (SECONDARY SOURCES). The "research" part of this enterprise is thus composed of the gathering, reading, and assimilation of these secondary sources. It also envisions the integration of it all in the body of your paper. The paper itself comes about as the result of a process of personal reflection. As a reader, you will be trying to sort out a troubling issue to you, a burning question, something that after consultation with your professor and reading some secondary sources, still fails to "make sense".
Coming up with a topic:
The most common mistake made by students comes at this stage.
Often students will pose overly ambitious questions: ie: "Philosophical
Implications of Borges's Narratives", "Death in Pedro Páramo", "Existentialist
Aspects of Cortázar's Hopscotch", or "Colombian History in García
Márquez's One Hundred Years of Solitude", etc.
Before you start working on something make sure that it is a
manageable project worth developing. The first step, after sorting
out an area of interest, is to narrow the topic and reduce its extension.
In this fashion your inquiry can attain a greater depth and possibly reach
truly interesting results.
The Topic and the Thesis:
A topic would remain an unfulfilled promise of knowledge if it
were not by the delineating virtues of a thesis. To do this you must
move beyond your general topic towards a good object of study, a thesis,
by means of relentless questioning. Your are trying to turn an idea
or a text into a problem the solution of which haunts you. St. Augustine's
words in his Confessions are helpful here: "mihi quaestio factus sum",
that is, "I became a problem [an object of study] to myself.
Bear in mind that these questions may come about as a result
of your own reading of the primary text or be found as you read through
your secondary sources. Ideally it would always be great to arrive
at a topic out of one's own curiosity, but often it is not the case.
Whichever way it may happen for you, be absolutely sure not to end up dabbling
in platitudes. If you fear that this might be the case come
and see me as soon as possible.
Looking Ahead:
A natural result of this effort is that after a while one begins
to see where one's ideas and points are leading. That is, you begin
to anticipate the conclusions of your research. If this happens more
or less steadily until the very end and/or beyond you are in luck.
Oftentimes though, one's conclusions evolve in ways that veer away and
even contradict one's stated thesis. If this happens to you are still
in luck, BUT you must go back to the beginning to reformulate your thesis
and re-write those parts of your argument that are not in agreement with
your conclusions.
Where Can I Begin...?
(A)- FIRST STEP: Think about what you have read and/or will read.
What have you liked about it? Do this during the first few weeks
of class and keep on doing it frequently. Carry these thoughts to
your Journal so that you may review them later. YOU MAY WORK ON A
BOOK THAT WE WILL READ TOWARDS THE END OF THE TERM IF YOU PLAN AHEAD.
(B)- SECOND STEP: Your course-packet contains detailed bio-bibliographical
and critical notes on each of the writers we will be dealing with.
Read these carefully to get an idea of what you would like to work on and
what other expert readers have deemed interesting in the area of your choice.
(C)- THIRD STEP: Use the resources available to you: SIMON, the Modern
Language Association Bibliography (MLA), the WWW, etc. in order to see
who has written on what and how does it illuminate or even change your
own perspective.
(D)- FOURTH STEP: Once this has been going on come and see me to talk
about it: Office Hrs: M-W-F: 11:00-11:45 and W-F: 16:00-16:45, or make
an appointment if you absolutely cannot make any of these times.
Paper Guidelines
1)- You will be penalized for not having a bibliography. A list
of works cited (bibliography). This is understood to be the list
of works (primary and secondary sources) that you have quoted. A minimum
of two bibliographical items is required.
a)- Bibliography:
SIMON: The library has a great many books on modern Latin American
fiction. Use SIMON and share your finds with your classmates.
In addition, the Library is now a member of ORBIS, a regional group of
libraries working together to make information available to you.
Remember that your classmates might need some of the books that you check
out.
The Modern Language Association Bibliography
(MLA) (available in paper {....-1981} and online {1982-199...}) is a fundamental
research tool. Articles unavailable in our library can be xeroxed
and delivered to Collins in a matter of hours or days. Ask your librarian.
Be resourceful: You live only 38 miles south of the 12th. best research
library in the United States of America. Visit the Suzallo and Allen
libraries at the University of Washington if you must. TIP: Make
a fun trip out of it and remember that there are express buses linking
downtown Tacoma with downtown Seattle running on the hour!
b)- Documentation:
Quoted material should be relevant not only to the paper in general,
but to the specific context in which it appears. A quote ought not
to stand on its own; it has to be an integral part of your discussion.
Frame every quote, that is, "sandwich" it between your own words.
2)- Use the MLA Style Manual when writing your paper especially when preparing your end-notes and the list of works cited.
The Paper Itself:
Have a clearly defined topic. Name it
in the title, describe it in the introductory paragraph, and develop it
through the body the text. Argue your points with elegance and substantiate
your assertions with ably selected quotes. Be persuasive and provocative
but never loud, presumptuous, or militant. You want to engage your
reader not to hit her over the head.
In the process of writing it is entirely possible that your ideas
may evolve in a way that contradicts your thesis. Were that to happen,
go back to your thesis and re-formulate it. Never lose sight of your
goals so as not to find that your point has disappeared after ten pages
of prose.
Some Useful Advice
1) Avoid topics that merely seek to confirm the presence of historical
facts in fiction, that is, avoid the obvious.
2) Avoid summaries of plot, characters, history, lectures, etc... which
again means: stay clear of what is obvious. You may need to re-tell
a particular point in the plot -that is OK-, but do not make recounting
the novel the purpose of your essay!
3) Avoid quoting from your class notes. Be extremely careful
if you must absolutely do so. Cite by the date and subject of the
lecture.
4) Avoid collages. Do not run from one idea to the other.
Not everything goes together. Run a tight ship with regards to your
thoughts. One well argued keen intuition is worth more than twenty
ill connected notions.
5) Do not write as if you, your classmates, and I were the only readers
in the universe. Your paper should be a readable experience for educated
human beings outside the context of Foreign Languages 380. TIP: Have
someone who is not enrolled in the class read your essay before handing
it in.
6) Avoid idiomatic expressions and conversational "style". ("The kind
of stuff that creeps into your paper, if you know what I mean": ie. "granted",
"impact" (used as a verb.), "bogus" (used as a slang term), "sort of...",
"right?", "ditto", etc.)
7) Avoid impressionistic language: "Borges is a great writer...",
"Pedro Páramo is an awful man...", etc. These type of statements
are "opinions" or "impressions" and add little or nothing to the presentation
of well thought ideas.
8) Say what you have to say; do not hide behind a "perhaps", a "maybe",
"who knows if...", etc. In a concluding sentence one "perhaps" may
make all the difference: ie. Saying: "Perhaps, it is this aspect
of Rulfo's fiction which is most relevant for readers today" is not as
convincing saying: "It is this aspect of Rulfo's fiction which is most
relevant for readers today".
9) DO WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO, BUT DO NOT TELL ME ABOUT IT IN THE PROCESS
OF DOING IT. Unless your paper deals with highly intricate developments
in literary theory there is no need to spell out your plan of attack: ie.
"In this paper I will first...". Remember that this paper is a short
piece and not a Senior Thesis. As, Nike, the sports gear manufacturer
preaches: "Just do it!". Present your thesis in the introductory
paragraph and dive into its development. If you do this in an organized
and eloquent way an educated reader will never lose your train of thought.
10) Do not hand in your paper without:
a) Re-reading it and proofreading it.
b) Stapling all the pages.
c) Carefully numbering each page if you have not done so already
before printing it.
d) Keeping a paper copy and a copy of the computer file in a
diskette until after final grades are posted!!!
11) Check and double-check for grammatical mistakes, spelling errors,
and style. TIP: It doesn't hurt to have someone at the Writing Center
read your stuff before handing it in.
12) Please, inspect the condition of your typewriter or printer ribbons
before you proceed. I will not read with a kind heart any paper that
is not printed legibly.
13) RULES ON PLAGIARISM WILL BE STRICTLY ENFORCED. Refer to the
Student Handbook. Be careful when paraphrasing others' thoughts.
Paraphrases ALSO have to be acknowledged. Document your sources fully.